DGatzby (and All),
Thanks for doing the legwork and documenting brake pad wear and usefulness. Valuable info. You've identified superior products compared to OEM, which cost less than OEM. That's good stuff!
At risk of blaspheming and bringing down lightning bolts from Mount Olympus...I resorted to picking up some front and rear AutoZone Duralast Gold Semi-Metallic brake pads for our Brembo brakes on the way to Putnam Park. Due to fallen trees in my front yard, a sick dog (he's better) and a delightful colonoscopy prep weekend and colonoscopy I neglected to get more Hawk DTC 60's from Lisa at Speedlogix in time (after selling them to a fellow Challenger owner in need at NCM). I got these best quality Duralast pads just in case I needed to get home - they claim to be made to replicate OEM Brembo pads. Fortunately I didn't need them after all. And I can return them, which I will probably do, but...
The box of the rear pads. Note the fine print saying their improved performance is independent lab tested compared to prior generation Duralast pads before May, 2010, so these current pads look to have been on the market for some time.
Front Box - the fine print says the graphic may not depict what is inside and that was definitely the case. Inside were 4 correct Brembo six caliper pads and their backing plates looked like the rear pad plates above - no rivets.
I bought both these front and rear pads for $114 out the door in Kentucky (including 6% tax). I looked them over carefully in my hotel room - looked high quality to my untrained eye. I tried to find some online reviews about them but failed. I did find one quite interesting YouTube video by a guy who used an NGS brake pad test machine to test a typical small sedan's OEM and then low, medium and higher cost representative part store brake pads. This machine tests for industry standard performance - coefficients of friction, corrosion resistance, etc., and the test rotor gets red hot. The video guy didn't test Hawks or Powerstop Extreme Performance Z-26's. It would be very interesting to see the graphs on both Hawk and Z-26's regarding fade, brake pedal pressure required to generate stopping power, and temperatures achieved during the testing compared to OEM and the much less expensive aftermarket pads. Some of the higher cost pads similar to the Duralast brand I picked up seemed to be working as well or better than OEM pads. I'd love to hear some opinions on this testing video.
Unless the Duralast Gold Semi-Metallic pads are dangerous junk that will likely catch fire on the track, ruin the rotors, or fade way too much, it begs the question...for $114 front and rear even if they wear out much faster (they might not) trackers could go through multiple sets of them and still come out significantly ahead financially. TD's breakout of road course track day costs was very useful - but probably financially sobering for people considering joining the ranks of road course enthusiasts and wondering about expenses. Maybe (Zeus, spare me for my blasphemy for I know not of what I speak!) things have changed in the last decade regarding AutoZone's (and other major retail parts supply stores) best grade brake pads?
The Dodge OEM Brembo's are almost shockingly expensive compared to these Duralasts and I'm never going to buy another set (plus the dust is incredible). Here's what my Dodge dealership quoted me on September 22, 2020;
Brembo 6 caliper Front pads $489 - Part # 68248384AC.
Brembo 4 caliper Rear pads $312 - Part # 68144223AC.
Total = $801, plus 6% tax is $849.
That's just shy of 7.5 times more expensive than the Duralast pads.
Aftermarket Hawk DTC-60's from Speedlogix, with shipping and a 10% discount, still totaled $516.96. I think you said you're getting 5 track days out of the Hawk DTC-70's (an even higher performance pad and a little more expensive than the 60's). Seems accurate to say using Hawks costs close to $100 per track day and using OEM pads more like $200 per track day.
Lastly...the use them all the time notion because they might just work and they are dustless and quiet and easy on the rotors...forgoing Hawk's and OEM and Duralast (and their comparable competitors)...how about just sticking with Z-26's? From Speedlogix's website - "Power Stop extreme pads are made for high performance street drivers who demand shorter stops under the most demanding conditions. The
Z26 brake torque is consistently higher than OE pads with outstanding thermal stability. Power Stop Extreme Performance pads are best suited for high horsepower cars and big wheel upgrades. The Z26 friction compound is a carbon fiber and ceramic hybrid that
resists fade to 1500 degrees. With Z26 pads, you can count on superior pad bite without dusty wheels."
I did see the disclaimer about "made for high performance street drivers", but isn't 1500 degrees a higher temperature than anyone could reasonably expect to see at an HPDE event? 20 to 30 minutes of hard use, then an hour of cool down? Are Hawk's rated higher than that? I just ran as hard as I could manage at Putnam Park five times on Saturday, for 30 minutes each session, with the hour cool down with my original OEM pads and they were consistently predictable stoppers with no detectable fade (I do have fresh Motul 600 racing brake fluid in my RE thanks to you clueing me in on that need). As far as I could tell I'd only just pulled off the freeway. If the Z-26's are better than my OEM pads right now are, well, I'd be a happy camper. Looking at Speedlogix's website we can buy front and rear Z-26 pads for our Brembo's for about $165 delivered to our homes. That's three sets of Z-26's for the price of one set of Hawk DTC 60's.
Am I missing something(s), or are the Powerstop higher torque and temperature claims exaggerated? I appreciate that TD and you are experts pushing the road course performance envelope - right to the edge - of what our cars can safely do. If I were in that league I'd probably not even be asking these questions. But for the 90% of Challenger owners who will by virtue of lesser skill sets or psychological barriers never operate their cars during HPDE at your level where's the value point in these brake pads?
Throwing all this out there looking for advice - thanks for reading - and standing by for incoming!
Best,
Finface